|
My Night with Maud (1969, Fr.) (aka
Ma Nuit Chez Maud, or My Night at Maud's)
In Eric Rohmer's 3rd film of his 'Six Moral Tales'
- an intelligent, dialogue-rich and dramatic romantic comedy about
life's chances and choices:
- in the opening sequence,
unnamed main character Jean-Louis ("J-L") (Jean-Louis
Trintignant), a 34 year-old smug, conflicted and uptight Catholic
civil engineer working for Michelin, attended Christmas Eve
Mass at a cathedral in Clermont-Ferrand; during the service, he
spotted a beautiful 22 year-old blonde girl Francoise (Marie-Christine
Barrault), a lab assistant; in voice-over, he obsessively vowed
to settle down and marry her (without really knowing her) as his
ideal woman: "I
suddenly knew, without a doubt, that Francoise would be my wife";
afterwards, in his car, he trailed after the elusive female on
her moped, but lost sight of her behind a slow-moving vehicle
- a discussion was held between the self-deceiving
and hypocritical J-L and his old Marxist high-school friend Vidal
(Antoine Vitez), a university philosophy teacher; one of their
subjects was Pascal's wager (they talked about playing the odds
regarding God's existence, because it was wiser to believe - since
if you're right, you go to heaven, but if you're wrong, you lose
nothing)
- a dinner conversation was
also held between J-L, Vidal and his free-thinking, wise and skeptical
brunette friend - a beautiful, vivacious divorcee single mother
and pediatrician named Maud (Françoise
Fabian) - a secular and modern female
- circumstances (a heavy snowfall) forced J-L
to stay over at Maud's place when she asked for "bedside company";
in a flirtatious sequence in Maud's bedroom, she temptingly
modeled a skimpy nightshirt to "show off" her legs, as
she admitted: "My only means of seduction"; J-L responded: "Not
the only means, but the best!"
- Maud stated that J-L had a complicated and conflicted
nature:
- "What troubles me the most about you is you're side-stepping.
You don't face your responsibilities. You're ashamed of being a Christian.
And ashamed of being a Don Juan!"
The Lengthy Bed Scene Conversation Between J-L
and Maud
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- in a lengthy scene, Maud and
J-L engaged in a self-reflective, challenging conversation about
sex and morality, including Maud's baring of her soul
about how she was unlucky in love - she sadly remembered and spoke
about her marriage, her own dead lover (killed in an icy car crash),
and her former husband's mistress:
- "You
really want to hear my life story? I had a lover and my husband,
a mistress. She was a little like you: very moral, Catholic.
Not a hypocrite, a sincere believer. But I hated her so much.
She was crazy about him. He's a guy that drives girls crazy.
I was crazy myself. I made him break with her. That was my
one good deed. She probably wouldn't have married him"
- Maud revealed that she had discarded
her nightshirt and was sleeping in the nude ("I always sleep
naked - nightclothes get so twisted around"); he reluctantly
joined her in the bed when she urged him to forsake an uncomfortable
armchair:
- "Don't
be childish. Come lie next to me. On the blankets. Or under - if
I'm not too ugly ....You'll have a cramp. Are you scared? Of yourself?
Of me? I swear I won't touch you. I thought you had self-control"
- he laid next to her on top of a thick, white-furred
coverlet (although he was clothed), because it was too cold and awkward
to sleep in a nearby armchair, and then tried to cover himself with
the blanket
- early the next morning, Maud made a clumsy attempt
at seduction and requesting sex from J-L, but he signaled that he
wanted to remain chaste; she jumped naked from bed and dismissed
him after he resisted her: "I like people who know what they
want";
soon after, he left her apartment
- later, circumstances also forced J-L to spend
a chaste, boring, and uninteresting night at Francoise's place -
a major contrast to his night with Maud
- outdoors, Francoise haltingly
confessed to J-L that she had very recently been engaged in an
affair with a married man:
- "I have a lover...until recently...I
loved him. Madly. I could say I've forgotten him but you can't
forget someone you've loved. We parted just before I met you...It's
all over. We'll never see each other again"
- she was forgiven by
J-L when he admitted he also had affairs:
- "Listen, Francoise.
We can wait as long as you want. You're wrong if you think it changes
anything for me. I have no right. Actually, I'm happy. It's true.
I felt uneasy before. Some of my affairs lasted a very long time.
Now we're even....I'll make a confession: The morning we meet,
I'd just left a girl. I'd slept with her"
- they mutually agreed
to never discuss their past sexual histories again
Meeting Up With Maud Five Years Later
|

Maud
|
|
|
Francoise with Husband J-L and Child
|
- the epilogue or closing scene of the film occurredfive
years later: it was a chance meeting at the beach between J-L (now
with wife Francoise and toddler son) and Maud, when it was revealed
- in an extraordinary and ironic coincidence - that she knew of Francoise:
("We know
each other - by sight"); Maud further recalled J-L's earlier
conversations with her about his future ideal fiancee (blonde and
Catholic); Maud told J-L that she had remarried, but it wasn't
going too well: ("I never have any luck with men")
- as
he joined up with Francoise already on the beach, J-L exclaimed: "I
didn't know you knew each other. When she left Clermont, I hardly
knew you. We had just met...You know, when I met you, I'd just
left her, but..."
- (J-L's voice over:
"I was to say: 'Nothing happened' - I saw that her embarrassment
didn't come from what she'd learned about me, but from what she guessed
I'd just learned about her. It suddenly hit me. Instead, I said...")
- "...That
was my last fling. It's odd that we bumped into her"
- he had
thoughtfully saved his wife embarrassment, by telling her that
Maud was the last affair he had in his past; Francoise was reassured
and again stated: "I find it rather funny. Anyway, all that was
so long ago. We said we'd never talk about it"
- the film ended
with the family happily running toward the water for a swim
|
Opening Cathedral Scene: "J-L" and Francoise
J-L's Friend Vidal with Maud
J-L's Sleep-Over with Sexy Maud
J-L's Contrasting, Boring Night With Francoise
Francoise's Confession to J-L of An Affair With a Married
Man
|